The Best Nipple Cream for Breastfeeding in 2024

Battling sore, cracked nipples from breastfeeding? You’re not alone, you just need some nipple cream. The right cream will soothe, moisturize, and help heal irritated nipples. 

At Aussie Bubs, we care about every step of your breastfeeding journey. That’s why we found the best nipple creams of 2024. Let’s dive in!

Best Overall: The Honest Company Calm Your Nip Balm

The Honest Company's Calm Your Nip Balm gets top marks from experts and moms alike. This multitasking balm is made with a dreamy blend of plant-based butters and oils that both heal and pamper delicate nipples.

The thick, velvety formula glides on and creates a nourishing protective layer over cracked and sore areas. Shea butter, coconut oil, and beeswax deeply hydrate while calming calendula takes the sting out of nursing. You can literally feel it soothing on contact. Better yet, the concentrated balm means a little goes a long way so the price tag doesn't hurt the budget quite as much.

Best Lanolin Formula: Lansinoh Lanolin Nipple Cream

For lanolin-based nipple creams, Lansinoh is the gold standard. Made from pure, medical-grade lanolin, it mimics the skin's natural oils to promote healing. Breastfeeding experts love that it's ultra-thick, fragrance-free, and a safe option to use while nursing. The cream provides long-lasting moisture without needing to be wiped off before feedings.



Best for Pumping: Bamboobies Boob-Ease Organic Pumping Lubricant

Pumping moms know how tough it can be to keep nipples from becoming raw and chafed. Bamboobies is a plant-based, USDA-certified organic lubricant designed specifically for making pumping sessions more comfortable. The smooth, non-sticky formula is nicely spreadable and free of any questionable ingredients that could contaminate breast milk.

Top Organic Pick: Motherlove Organic Nipple Cream

Free of any synthetic ingredients, this 100% organic nipple cream earns high marks for efficacy and purity. Herbal oils like calendula and marshmallow root help relieve tenderness and inflammation. Since it's totally safe for your bub, there's no need to remove it before nursing. 

Best Vegan Option: Bella B Nipple Nurture Butter

For plant-based mamas, Bella B's uber-nourishing nipple butter cream is a fantastic lanolin-free option. It combines a variety of rich plant butters and oils like avocado, coconut, and mango to create a hydrating, protective barrier. The subtle natural scent is lovely and the formula is EWG-verified.

Best Dual-Purpose Pick: Natalist Nip & Lip Balm

Convenience is key for busy new moms, which is why Natalist's 2-in-1 Nip & Lip Balm is a smart choice. This multitasking formula does double duty as both a nipple cream and lip balm. The smooth, non-sticky blend of plant butters and oils like coconut, mango and rosehip deeply nourishes dry, cracked areas. It's also lanolin and fragrance-free, making it ideal for those with sensitivities. The portable twist-up tube makes it easy to moisturize lips and nipples on-the-go.

Best for Severe Cracking: Mommy Knows Best Organic Soothing Nipple Cream

When nipples are severely damaged and cracked, you need a heavy-hitter cream with major healing properties. Mommy Knows Best is a top pick for providing fast relief to unbearably raw, blistered nipples. This certified organic formula harnesses the power of anti-inflammatory herbs like calendula and chamomile to calm fire-like pain upon contact. Nutrient-rich oils deeply replenish and the thick, luxe balm creates a softening barrier to allow skin to repair itself.

Best Organic Lanolin Option: Lansinoh Organic Nipple Balm

While many moms swear by classic lanolin nipple creams, others prefer an organic alternative. Lansinoh's organic lanolin balm delivers the same deep moisturizing benefits in a clean, green formula. It's USDA certified 100% organic and free of preservatives, parabens, and fragrances. The super thick and concentrated texture creates a second-skin barrier to protect against friction while allowing nipples to heal. Since it's hypoallergenic and baby-safe, there's no need to remove it before breastfeeding.

Best All-Natural Multitasker: Bamboobies Organic Nipple Balm

Bamboobies gets another nod for their super versatile organic nipple balm. This thick, rich USDA organic formula is handcrafted from just four ingredients: organic beeswax, shea butter, coconut oil, and non-nano zinc oxide. It's 100% natural and safe for both baby and mom to ingest. Use it as a healing nipple balm, diaper rash ointment, dry skin salve...the uses are endless! It's a true everyday multi-tasker.

Other Highly Rated Picks

Matterna Organic Nipple Cream, Tiny Human Organic Nipple Balm, and Earth Mama Angel Baby Nipple Butter are a few other standout organic and vegan nipple creams getting rave reviews in 2024.

Matterna's formula contains just six simple ingredients like olive oil, beeswax and herbs to naturally moisturize and protect. Tiny Human's balm blends coconut oil and shea butter for an ultra-nourishing treat. And Earth Mama's cult-favorite butter is a non-GMO, lanolin-free option that soothes on contact.

These multi-purpose balms can double as lip soothers and dry skin relievers. Their clean, gentle formulas make them safe for use on delicate nursing nipples without having to remove before feedings.

Tips for Choosing the Right Nipple Cream

With so many options, here are some key considerations to help you pick the perfect nipple cream.

Dietary Preferences

Those looking to avoid animal products will want to stick to vegan, lanolin-free formulas. Lanolin is more traditional but can cause sensitivity for some.


Think about how quickly and cleanly a cream absorbs so you don't have to remove residue before nursing. Thicker balms may require more massaging in.


Seek out ultra-hydrating and protective ingredients like plant butters, oils and ceramides. Avoid anything too thin or containing potential irritants.

Specific Needs

Cracked nipples crave maximum healing power, while pumping calls for nipple lubricants that won't degrade flanges.


Organic and vegan nipple creams can be pricier than lanolin-based ones. But a little goes a long way so they're a worthwhile investment.

What brings relief for one mom may not work for another. Read reviews, sample a few different formulas, and don't hesitate to swap creams until you find your perfect nurturing fit!

If you’re still looking for the perfect baby formula, Aussie Bubs has you covered. We offer the highest quality Australian goat milk formula, infant formula, and so much more.