The Best Bottles for Breastfed Babies - 2024

Breastfeeding provides numerous benefits for both mom and baby, but at some point, many nursing parents need to introduce a bottle. Whether you're returning to work, want to share feeding responsibilities with your partner, or simply need a break from breastfeeding, choosing one of the best bottles for breastfed babies is crucial.

An ill-fitting bottle can lead to nipple confusion, fussiness, and potentially impact your baby's willingness to continue breastfeeding. That's why in this article, we'll dive into the key factors to consider when selecting a bottle, incorporating advice from renowned pediatrician Dr. Tanya Altmann.

From nipple design and material safety to ease of cleaning and size considerations, we'll cover everything you need to know to make an informed decision. Our goal is to help you find a bottle that not only meets your baby's needs but also supports a smooth transition between breast and bottle.

So, whether you're a first-time parent navigating the world of bottle feeding or an experienced caregiver seeking a better option, we'll help you find the right bottle for your breastfed baby.

Why Use Bottles for Breastfed Babies?

Breastfeeding is a natural process, but there are times when a mother needs to use a bottle. Whether it's because you're returning to work, your baby is struggling with latching, or you simply need a break, using a bottle provides a practical solution.

A bottle that closely mimics the breastfeeding experience can make the transition easier for breastfed babies. Additionally, the right bottle can also have a significant impact on a baby's health. Some bottles are designed to reduce the amount of air a baby swallows during feeding, which can help prevent gas and colic.

Best Types of Bottles for Breastfed Babies

Not all bottles are equal, and the type of bottle you choose can make a significant difference. Here's a closer look at the most common types of bottles for breastfed babies.

Anti-Colic Bottles

Anti-Colic Bottles

Anti-colic bottles are specifically designed to reduce the amount of air a baby ingests during feeding. They feature unique venting systems that eliminate air bubbles in the milk or formula, which can lead to gas, discomfort, and colic in babies. 

"For babies with feeding issues such as gas or colic, I usually recommend a bottle with a valve venting system to help decrease the amount of air that a baby can take in when feeding." - Tanya Altmann, MD, FAAP

A valve venting system typically has a one-way valve that allows air to escape from the bottle as your baby feeds, preventing excess air from mixing with the milk or formula. 

By minimizing air intake, these bottles help make feeding more comfortable for your baby, leading to less fussiness and more enjoyable feeding sessions. The venting systems in these bottles also help preserve the nutrients in breast milk or formula by preventing oxidation.

The Best Anti-Colic Bottles:

  • Dr. Brown's Options+ Anti-Colic Bottle: This is one of the most highly recommended anti-colic bottles by experts and parents. It features a vent system that helps prevent air bubbles and reduce colic, spit-up, and burping.
  • Philips Avent Anti-Colic Bottle: Another top choice, these bottles have a unique valve integrated into the nipple that draws air away from the milk to prevent excessive air intake.

Natural-Feel Bottles

Natural Feel Bottles

Natural-feel bottles aim to closely mimic the breastfeeding experience to make the transition from breast to bottle easier for your baby. They feature nipples that are wide and soft, similar to a mother's breast, which can help your baby latch more easily. 

"For babies with nipple confusion or who may have trouble latching onto the breast after bottle feeding, try a wider bottle with a wide, soft, flexible nipple that more closely mimics feeding at the breast." - Tanya Altmann, MD, FAAP

Some natural-feel bottles also have flexible bodies that allow your baby to control the flow of milk, just like they would when breastfeeding. This can help prevent overfeeding and make feeding more comfortable for your baby.

The Best Natural-Feel Bottles:
  • Comotomo Baby Bottle: With its soft, squeezable body and wide-shaped nipple, the Comotomo closely mimics breastfeeding. It's a favorite among lactation consultants and breastfeeding mothers.
  • NUK Simply Natural Bottle: The nipple on these bottles is designed to mimic the shape and feel of a real breast, helping babies latch on easily and avoid nipple confusion.

Glass Bottles

Glass Bottles

Glass bottles are a durable and eco-friendly option for parents who prefer a more natural material. Unlike plastic, glass doesn't absorb odors or flavors, so your baby's milk will taste as fresh as possible. 

Glass bottles are also often easier to clean than plastic bottles, as they don't stain or retain residue. However, they are heavier and can break more easily, so they aren’t the best option for older babies who like to hold their own bottles. 

The Best Glass Bottles:

Plastic Bottles

Plastic Bottles

Plastic bottles are a popular choice because of their lightweight and unbreakable nature. They are easy to handle, both for parents and for older babies learning to hold their own bottles. Modern plastic bottles are made from safe materials that are free from harmful chemicals like BPA. However, it's important to replace plastic bottles and nipples regularly as they can wear out over time. 

The Best Plastic Bottles:

Silicone Bottles

Sillicone Bottles

Silicone bottles offer the best of both worlds. They are soft and flexible like natural breasts, which can make them more acceptable to breastfed babies who refuse harder bottles. Silicone is also a very safe material that is heat-resistant and free from harmful chemicals. These bottles are unbreakable and often have a wide design that is easy to clean. However, silicone bottles can be more expensive than other types. 

The Best Silicone Bottles:

What to Look for in a Bottle for a Breastfed Baby

"Key factors for parents to consider when choosing a bottle for their breastfed baby are the size, shape and material of the nipple. Often a wide bottle with a wide, soft, flexible nipple can more closely mimic feeding at the breast and make it easier for the baby to go back and forth between breastfeeding and bottle feeding." - Tanya Altmann, MD, FAAP, Pediatrician, Founder of Calabasas Pediatrics

Nipple Design

The nipple plays a crucial role in ensuring a seamless transition between breastfeeding and bottle feeding. A wide, soft, and flexible nipple can mimic the shape and feel of a mother's breast, helping the baby latch on comfortably and reduce the risk of nipple confusion. Look for nipples made from soft, pliable materials that allow for a natural sucking motion.

Material Safety

The safety of the materials used in bottles is a top priority for many parents. Opt for bottles made from safe, non-toxic materials that are free from harmful chemicals like BPA. Glass and silicone bottles are popular choices, as they are considered safer and more eco-friendly than plastic alternatives.

Ease of Cleaning

Keeping bottles clean and sterilized is essential for your baby's health. Look for bottles with wide necks and fewer parts, as they are generally easier to clean thoroughly. Bottles with a simple design and minimal nooks and crannies can save you time and effort during cleaning.

Size and Capacity

The size and capacity of the bottle should align with your baby's age and feeding habits. Newborns typically require smaller bottles, while older babies may need larger ones to accommodate their growing appetites. Bottles with clear measurement markings can help ensure accurate feeding and prevent overfeeding or underfeeding.

By considering these factors, you can choose a bottle that not only meets your breastfed baby's needs but also makes the transition between breastfeeding and bottle feeding as smooth as possible.

When to Introduce Bottles and Start Pumping

One of the biggest questions for breastfeeding moms is when is the right time to introduce a bottle and start pumping breast milk. Dr. Tanya Altmann provides some guidance:

"Once breastfeeding is well established, around 2 to 4 weeks of age, is a good time to begin pumping and storing your breastmilk. This will allow other caregivers to feed and bond with baby. It's usually a good idea to offer your baby a bottle at least once a day so they remember how to drink from a bottle. Offering baby a bottle by 1 month of age will allow them to learn to drink from a bottle and remain familiar with it. This can allow a breastfeeding mom more flexibility, as others can feed and bond with the baby as well."

Waiting until breastfeeding is going smoothly before introducing a bottle can help prevent nipple confusion and ensure your baby has mastered a proper latch. However, many experts recommend getting baby used to bottle feeding within the first 4-6 weeks to avoid bottle refusal later on.

When pumping, be sure to use bottles and accessories designed for breast milk storage and handling. Look for bottles with volume markings to accurately measure intake and materials that protect valuable breast milk nutrients during refrigeration or freezing.

By slowly transitioning your baby to take an occasional bottle, you can maintain your breastfeeding routine while still having the flexibility to have others help with feedings. Just take it slowly, watch for cues that baby is ready, and keep breastfeeding as your priority in those early weeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

You've got questions? We've got answers.

Can I mix breastmilk and formula in the same bottle?

Yes, you can mix breastmilk and formula in the same bottle, but it's important to prepare the formula correctly before adding it to the breastmilk. Make sure to follow the formula manufacturer's instructions precisely for measurements and water temperature. Once prepared, let the formula cool completely before combining it with your refrigerated breastmilk.

How many bottles do I need for a breastfed baby?

The number can vary based on your feeding routine, but a good rule of thumb is:

  • If only using occasionally: 2-4 bottles
  • If supplementing regularly: 4-6 bottles
  • If exclusively bottle-feeding: 8-10 bottles

It's best to have enough to allow for cleaning between uses. Babies tend to prefer feeding from the same bottle each time, so having multiples of their favorite can be helpful.

At what age can I introduce a bottle?

Most lactation consultants recommend introducing a bottle around 2-4 weeks after birth, once breastfeeding is well established. However, every baby is different, so follow your pediatrician's guidance. Holding off too long can lead to bottle refusal.

How do I prevent nipple confusion?

Use bottles with a slow, newborn flow nipple that mimics a breast's natural pace. Avoid lengthy bottle times by alternating breasts and paced bottle feedings. You can also try using a bottle nipple made of thin, flexible silicone that feels more like skin.

Do I need special bottles for breastmilk?

While regular bottles work fine for breastmilk, some parents prefer bottles and accessories designed for breastmilk storage and handling. Look for bottles with volume markings, lids for fridge/freezer storage, and materials that protect nutrients.

How do I transition back to breastfeeding after bottle use?

Be patient and consistent. Start by giving a bottle before putting baby to breast. Skin-to-skin contact and experiment with positioning. Don't get discouraged - with time, most babies can switch back smoothly.